Hilbert's infinite hotel paradox

For English-speaking people, here is a mailI wrote and sent to explain to an Australian guy he was wrong to think that the series 1,2,3,4,... was twice as numerous as the series 2,4,6,8,... :
I also took the opportunity to make a litle fun about French and English people :)

The series 1,2,3,4,... (whole numbers) is an infinite series, true.
The series 2,4,6,8,... (even numbers) is also an infinite series, which is the exact same size (or, cardinal) than the first one, or the the odd numbers 1,3,5,7,...

To see that, during one of your sleepless nights, you can think about the example of the Infinite Hotel of Hilbert (famous French mathematician). If you have some courage, you can try and read my long paragraph below :
Here it is :

If a hotel in London has an infinite number of rooms, numbered 1,2,3,4,5,... , and one night the hotel is completely full with French tourists (all rooms are occupied by a French client, I know that is a lot of clients (if not, a lot of French)). What happens if a new client comes along to sleep ? Will the hotel receptionist say 'No, sorry, no room left' ? 

Not at all, he will just say to every French client : 'Please, can you please move to the room that has one number higher than yours, please ? ' (all the 'please' because this hotel is in England, of course)
And, problem solved, since room number 1 will be free for the newcomer (the former French client of room number 1 is now in room 2, then the former French of room 2 is in room 3, etc).

But, but .... what if an infinite bus comes along full up with an infinite number of English clients ? They all come down one after the other in a big infinite rush, to try and have a room in the Infinite Hotel (they don't know it is full (if they knew it was full with French, they would go elsewhere I'm sure), and they really want to sleep. Have you already seen a big rush of an infinite number of English tourists ? It is very strange because it is all very organized for a rush, nobody tries to go over in the queue, they just speed up to the reception but then wait for their turn ^^)

Well, so the receptionist is very puzzled, he is about to refuse all the other clients but the first one (with the same trick as before he can fit one customer, then another one, then another one, etc, but he can't keep asking his French clients to move up a room, every time a new English client comes along, they would keep moving for infinite time if they want to fit the infinite bus of English ! And the French all want to sleep, so, no good).

Suddenly, a brilliant idea comes up his mind (and pay attention here, because it explains why there is the same amount of whole numbers than of even numbers) : he asks all his French clients to go to the room with the even number that is double of his own number : for example, client in room 1 goes to room 2, client in room 2 goes to room 4, client in room 3 goes to room 6, client in room 4 goes to room 8, etc ...

Everyone can agree that :

1) All the French clients know exactly where they are supposed to go (but will they manage in no mess ? After all, they are French)
2) They have only one choice in where to go to spend their night
3) They can't find a room already occupied, since for instance the client in room 1 goes to room 2, but room 2 would be empty since the client in room 2 would go in room 4, etc 
4) The infinity of French clients have accommodation, AND they leave an infinite number of empty rooms (all the odd ones : 1, 3, 5, 7, etc, will be free) where the receptionist can now fit in the whole infinity of English tourists from the bus.

One might wonder, why such a brilliant man with such clever ideas is still "only" a receptionist in a hotel ? Maybe because it is Hilbert's infinite hotel, so everyday is a challenge ...

Mathematical corner (for non-allergic) :
This in maths is called a bijection, showing that 2 sets of numbers (or other stuff also) have the same "cardinal" by finding a way of relating one and only one element from the first set, to one and only one element of the second set, so that all elements are related in a one-to-one way. 
We say that to element "n" of the whole numbers, we relate element "2n" (his double) of the even numbers, it shows that there is the same cardinal in both the set of whole numbers, and the set of even numbers.
Like I said before :
1 <-> 2
2 <-> 4
3 <-> 6
4 <-> 8
5 <-> 10

Commentaires (9)

1. arthritis (site web) 29/10/2012

I came across epsilonpi.e-monsite.com and i love it !
what is arthritis


2. betonboxing (site web) 20/08/2012

epsilonpi.e - monsite.com est mon numéro 1 site maintenant


Robert Stieglitz Arthur Abraham odds
Dan Henderson Jon Jones betting

3. Cheap-windows7key 20/06/2012

Product activation monitors the system configuration. If it detects a major hardware change or even too many minor hardware changes within a set number of days (I believe it's 180 days before it resets) then it crosses the threshold buy new activation key windows 7 and requires reactivation. Your windows vista activation key operating system is now reinstalled on your reformatted hard drive, and you are all activated without having to actually go through the pro

4. air Jordan (site web) 15/03/2012

Jordan is a world famous brand, is a favorite of sports shoes.Nike air Jordan sale online now,Thousands of people like to air Jordan sneakers.Because it is a first-class quality and best.It made ??me full passionate and strength service.Now wholesale air Jordan shoes online store.Enjoy shopping in cheap shoes Jordan outlet.

5. mulberry bags sale (site web) 24/02/2012

March, Picnic take you to a picnic, picnic cloth of blue and white squares, put all

kinds of desserts, mulberry bags,candy and playing cards, the day is a good mood. The happy Quilting

is a lavender tone monochrome printing,
mulberry handbags, the quilted fabric surface coupled with the

butterfly pattern of suture, filled with happiness and warmth of feeling.mulberry bags sale, Floral in Perf

printing using the new technology of hollow,

6. air jordans (site web) 24/02/2012

Jordan Sports formerly established in 1984, Jinjiang City, Fujian Province, Chen Tai

stream Commodity Plant, are collectively owned enterprises, and by the small old-year-

old, father and son Ding Guoxiong inject 13.6 million to set up, anchored Village

committee. buy jordans online.At present, the company's actual control of human Dingguo Xiong and small

rule couple,buy jordans, mainly engaged in the design, production and sales of sports shoes, sports

apparel, sports accessories products.

7. replica rolex submariner (site web) 21/02/2012

Thank you for sharing contents of the article very well. Click here to move your mouse, you can see breitling navitimer replica replica rolex submariner .Using the successful rise of the replica company, it has become hard to inform which is actually fake and that is genuine.

8. Patricia Colon 21/02/2012

This picture is very beautiful. I like it very much. This picture of the effect is very good.Click here oris replica watches

9. vivienne westwood bag (site web) 19/02/2012

<p>you will be able would your artful shoe. you will be able would your your own warm trunk yet you the sweet women. which means that while you yourself you've Vivienne Westwood Melissa your dream now, you yourself you'd you should be would willing you will see that work for your wrapping up visual working in your perfect manner. worse resoundingly, Vivienne Westwood Melissa trunk you'd yet to be you just with all upward your traits glamour impeccably yet you should also your low your style working in your wonderful manner. what's more <strong>Vivienne Westwood Jewellery</strong> Vivienne Westwood Melissa what to wear trunk you'd yet to be you just perk upward <strong>Vivienne Westwood Jewelry</strong> your sunless shooting yet you should also work for your thoughts wish lastingly. </p><p>Louis Vuitton purses would be your dream you will see that you should be you use within your years occasions.No you want within your christmas party,anniversary,Christmas day,New year's time,Easter vs you the like,they you

Ajouter un commentaire

Créer un site gratuit avec e-monsite - Signaler un contenu illicite sur ce site